[Bldg-sim] Mixed-Use project with multiple meters - Match Proposed or Reality?

[Robby Oylear]

I have a multifamily project which will have a noresidential electricity
meter to cover house loads and a residential electrical meter for each
unit.  The baseline system is System 2 - PTHP's.  The proposed system is
Chilled Water with Electric Heat.  Due to the rate structures out here in
Seattle, I'm noticing that the virtual rate in the baseline is
approximately 10% higher than in the proposed.  I've tracked it down mainly
to the fact that the baseline "Space Cooling" usage is allocated to the
Residential meters while the Proposed "Space Cooling" is provided by a
chiller that will be on a nonresidential meter.  In reality, a terminal
piece of equipment within a residence would be metered by the residential
panel and charged direct to the residence.  However, it seems a bit unfair
that the baseline is being penalized strictly based on which meter the
"Space Cooling" is assigned to.

I can't find anything specifically within Appendix G that would tell me to
have the same energy meters or rate structure by system.  The LEED
Reference Guide provides guidance that says the same rate schedules shall
be used for the proposed and baseline simulations and building.

Mixed-use buildings seem to be a weak point of Appendix G and I'm wondering
if anyone else has run into this issue before.

Thanks,

Robby Oylear, PE, LEED AP
Mechanical Engineer
Senior Energy Analyst

D 206-788-4571
www.rushingco.com
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.onebuilding.org/pipermail/bldg-sim-onebuilding.org/attachments/20120905/79154aa7/attachment.htm>